Urine drug testing is a crucial part of many companies’ hiring and compliance programs. But with various types of drug tests available—like the 5 panel and 10 panel urine drug tests—employers often face a key question: Which test is the best fit for your company’s needs?
In this guide, we’ll break down the differences between the 5 panel and 10 panel urine drug tests, their benefits, use cases, and how to choose the right one based on your industry, workforce, and legal requirements.
What Is a Urine Drug Test?
A urine drug test screens an individual’s urine sample to detect the presence of certain drugs and their metabolites. It's one of the most commonly used drug screening methods due to its ease of use, cost-effectiveness, and ability to detect recent drug use.
What Is a 5 Panel Urine Drug Test?
The 5 panel urine drug test screens for the most commonly abused substances. It is often used by federally regulated industries (like DOT) and for pre-employment testing.
Drugs Tested in a 5 Panel Test:
-
Marijuana (THC)
-
copyright
-
Opiates (Codeine, Morphine, Heroin)
-
Amphetamines (including Methamphetamine)
-
Phencyclidine (PCP)
Use Cases:
-
DOT-regulated industries (trucking, aviation, transit)
-
Safety-sensitive positions
-
Pre-employment and random testing
-
Companies looking to comply with federal testing guidelines
What Is a 10 Panel Urine Drug Test?
The 10 panel urine drug test expands on the 5 panel test by screening for additional prescription and recreational drugs. This test is typically used by employers in non-regulated industries who want a broader view of employee substance use.
Drugs Tested in a 10 Panel Test:
Includes the same 5 substances as above, plus:
6. Barbiturates
7. Benzodiazepines
8. Methadone
9. Methaqualone (Quaaludes)
10. Propoxyphene (Darvon)
Use Cases:
-
Healthcare, hospitality, and construction industries
-
Employers concerned about prescription drug abuse
-
Post-accident or reasonable suspicion testing
-
Organizations with stricter workplace drug policies
Key Differences Between 5 Panel and 10 Panel Drug Tests
| Feature | 5 Panel Test | 10 Panel Test |
|---|---|---|
| Number of Substances Tested | 5 | 10 |
| Includes Prescription Drugs | No | Yes (Benzos, Barbiturates, etc.) |
| Regulatory Use | Common in DOT/federal guidelines | Typically used in non-regulated settings |
| Cost | Lower | Slightly higher |
| Testing Depth | Basic screen for illicit drugs | Broader screening, including Rx drugs |
Which Drug Test Is Right for Your Company?
Choose a 5 Panel Drug Test If:
-
You operate in a federally regulated industry (like transportation or aviation)
-
You're implementing a basic pre-employment drug screen
-
Your company wants to minimize testing costs while still ensuring safety
Choose a 10 Panel Drug Test If:
-
Your workforce may have access to prescription medications or opioids
-
You’re in an industry with higher substance use risk
-
You want to implement stricter drug-free workplace policies
Legal and Compliance Considerations
When choosing between a 5 or 10 panel test, consider:
-
State laws: Some states restrict or regulate testing for certain drugs.
-
Privacy concerns: Testing for prescription drugs may raise HIPAA or ADA concerns.
-
Federal guidelines: DOT and other federal agencies typically require 5 panel testing.
Always consult legal counsel or an HR professional to ensure your company’s drug testing policy is compliant with local and federal laws.
Final Thoughts
Choosing between a 5 panel and a 10 panel urine drug test comes down to your industry, risk level, and compliance requirements. While the 5 panel test is ideal for standard screening, the 10 panel test offers a more comprehensive snapshot—especially if your workforce is at higher risk for prescription drug misuse.
Whichever you choose, ensure your drug testing program is clear, consistent, and legally compliant to foster a safer, more productive workplace.